Obesity won’t be solely defined by BMI under new plan for diagnosis by global experts

A gaggle of world specialists is proposing a brand new strategy to outline and diagnose weight problems, decreasing the emphasis on the controversial physique mass index and hoping to raised determine individuals who want remedy for the illness attributable to extra physique fats.

Beneath suggestions launched Tuesday night time, weight problems would not be outlined solely by BMI, a calculation of peak and weight, however mixed with different measurements, reminiscent of waist circumference, plus proof of well being issues tied to further kilos.

Weight problems is estimated to have an effect on greater than 1 billion folks worldwide. Within the U.S., about 40% of adults have weight problems, in line with the U.S. Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention.

“The entire objective of that is to get a extra exact definition in order that we’re focusing on the individuals who really need the assistance most,” stated Dr. David Cummings, an weight problems knowledgeable on the College of Washington and one of many 58 authors of the report printed in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology journal.

The report introduces two new diagnostic classes: medical weight problems and pre-clinical weight problems.

Individuals with medical weight problems meet BMI and different markers of weight problems and have proof of organ, tissue or different issues attributable to extra weight. That would embrace coronary heart illness, hypertension, liver or kidney illness or persistent extreme knee or hip ache. These folks can be eligible for remedies, together with weight loss plan and train interventions and weight problems drugs.

Individuals with pre-clinical weight problems are in danger for these circumstances, however haven’t any ongoing sickness, the report says.

BMI has lengthy been thought of a flawed measure that may over-diagnose or underdiagnose weight problems, which is at present outlined as a BMI of 30 or extra. However folks with extra physique fats don’t all the time have a BMI above 30, the report notes. And other people with excessive muscle mass—soccer gamers or different athletes—could have a excessive BMI regardless of regular fats mass.

Beneath the brand new standards, about 20% of people that was labeled as overweight would not meet the definition, preliminary evaluation suggests. And about 20% of individuals with critical well being results however decrease BMI would now be thought of clinically overweight, specialists stated.

“It would not dramatically change the proportion of individuals being outlined as having weight problems, however it could higher diagnose the individuals who actually have clinically important extra fats,” Cummings stated.

The brand new definitions have been endorsed by greater than 75 medical organizations around the globe, but it surely’s not clear how broadly or shortly they may very well be adopted in apply. The report acknowledges that implementation of the suggestions “will carry important prices and workforce implications.”

A spokesman for the medical insurance commerce group AHIP, previously often known as America’s Well being Insurance coverage Plans, stated “it is too early at this level to gauge how plans will incorporate these standards into protection or different insurance policies.”

There are sensible points to contemplate, stated Dr. Katherine Saunders, an weight problems knowledgeable at Weill Cornell Medication and co-founder of the weight problems remedy firm FlyteHealth. Measuring waist circumference sounds easy, however protocols differ, many docs aren’t educated precisely and commonplace medical tape measures aren’t large enough for many individuals with weight problems.

As well as, figuring out the distinction between medical and pre-clinical weight problems would require a complete well being evaluation and lab checks, she famous.

“For a brand new classification system to be broadly adopted, it could additionally should be extraordinarily fast, cheap, and dependable,” she stated.

The brand new definitions are prone to be complicated, stated Kate Bauer, a vitamin knowledgeable on the College of Michigan College of Public Well being.

“The general public likes and wishes easy messages. I do not assume this differentiation goes to alter something,” she stated.

Overhauling the definition of weight problems will take time, acknowledged Dr. Robert Kushner, an weight problems knowledgeable on the Northwestern Feinberg College of Medication and a co-author of the report.

“This is step one within the course of,” he stated. “I believe it will start the dialog.”

© 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials might not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.